ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 1 of 18
12/20/2012

Approved as Submitted
TAC Recommendation
Ü
Total Mods for reports:  80
Total Mods for  Roofing in  Approved as Submitted
TAC: 
Roofing
 18
SubCode
Building
Ü
15‑Roof Assemblies and Rooftop Structures
Section
1507.2.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5360 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.  Provide correct Types for previously approved ASTM D 4869.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
1507.2.8 Underlayment application.
Mark Zehnal
 5562 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
1507.4.5 Underlayment and high wind.
Mark Zehnal
 5563 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
1507.5.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5564 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 2 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  Approved as Submitted
TAC: 
Roofing
 18
Section
1507.6.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5565 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
1507.7.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5566 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
1507.8.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5567 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
1507.9.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5568 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

SubCode
Existing Building
Ü
2‑Definitions

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 3 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  Approved as Submitted
TAC: 
Roofing
 18
Section
202
Ken Cureton
 5937 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Modify SECTION 202 (Roofing TAC)
2
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G3

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 & G4– no action need
G3 – 9Y -0N
G4 no action needed

G1 & G4
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

4‑Prescriptive Compliance Method
Section
412
Ken Cureton
 5940 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Add SECTION 412
4
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G3
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G3 – 9Y-0N
G1 & G4 no action needed

G1 and G4
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

7‑Alterations ‑ Level 1
Section
711
Mark Zehnal
 5239 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Move current Florida‑specific criteria to Residential Code.
7
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

SubCode
Residential
Ü
9‑Roof Assemblies
Section
R905.10.5 Underlayment and high wind.
Mark Zehnal
 5561 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y - 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 4 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  Approved as Submitted
TAC: 
Roofing
 18
Section
R905.2.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5485 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria for shingle underlayment. Provide correct Types for previously approved ASTM D 4869.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A!
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
R905.2.7 Underlayment Application.
Mark Zehnal
 5555 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
2Y – 7N

A!
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
R905.4.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5556 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 2Y -7N

A!
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
R905.4.4 Material standards.
Mark Zehnal
 5508 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 3Y – 6N

G!
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

Section
R905.5.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5513 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.Provide correct Types for previously approved ASTM D 4869.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 2Y 7N

A!
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 5 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  Approved as Submitted
TAC: 
Roofing
 18
Section
R905.5.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5557 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 2Y – 7N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
Approved as Submitted

W

No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC Recommendation
Ü
Total Mods for reports:  80
Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
SubCode
Building
Ü
15‑Roof Assemblies and Rooftop Structures
Section
1503.6 Crickets and saddles.
Mark Zehnal
 5347 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria
15
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G3, -3Y – 6N
G2, 6-3
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.2.7.1 Wind Resistance of Asphalt Shingles
Mark Zehnal
 5363 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 8Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.3 Clay and concrete tile.
Mark Zehnal
 5587 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

G2 – 6Y-3N
G3 – 3Y -6N

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 6 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
1507.3.3.1
Mark Zehnal
 5590 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.3.3
Mark Zehnal
 5589 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.3.6
Mark Zehnal
 5591 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.3.7
Mark Zehnal
 5592 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.3.8
Mark Zehnal
 5593 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 7 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
1507.3.9
Mark Zehnal
 5594 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.4 Metal roof panels.
Mark Zehnal
 5275 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N
G1 – 0Y-9N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.4.5 Underlayment
Mark Zehnal
 5386 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.6 Mineral‑surfaced roll roofing.
Mark Zehnal
 5278 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.7 Slate shingles.
Mark Zehnal
 5281 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 8 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
1507.8 Wood shingles.
Mark Zehnal
 5286 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.9 Wood shakes.
Mark Zehnal
 5284 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507.9.2 Deck slope.
Mark Zehnal
 5405 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1507
Mark Zehnal
 5268 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1508.1 General
Deborah Lawson
 5738 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Use of above‑deck thermal insulation ‑‑ adds Factory Mutual reference for cellular concrete.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 8Y – 1N
G1 – no action needed

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 9 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
1509.6.4 Equipment and appliances on roofs or elev
Mark Zehnal
 5411 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 7Y – 2N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1509.6.5 Mechanical units.
Mark Zehnal
 5412 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1509
Mark Zehnal
 5288 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 8Y -1N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1510
Mark Zehnal
 5291 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
1510
Katherine Cleary
 5731 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Vague code language. Set forth  an allowable moistre by weight content
roof membrane and insulation will give determine the suitabilty of the existing roof to receive a re‑roof or a re‑cover.
15
Proponent

x
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A2 – 2Y -7N

A2
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 10 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
1517.3 through 1517.6
Deborah Lawson
 5742 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Existing section 1917 is a Florida‑specific code not in the base code. It is of importance to Florida including HVHZs. FRDA believes LWIC is more appropriate to address in the Roofing Insulation Code since it is a roofing insulation material.
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
Table 1503.2
Mark Zehnal
 5612 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
15
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
TABLE 1507.4.3(1) METAL ROOF COVERINGS
Mark Zehnal
 5414 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 Florida Building Code specific criteria.
15
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 8Y – 1N
G1 – 1Y – 8N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

SubCode
Existing Building
Ü
7‑Alterations ‑ Level 1
Section
711
Mark Zehnal
 5241 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
7
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G2
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G2 – 9Y – 0N
G1 – 0Y – 9N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

SubCode
Residential
Ü
9‑Roof Assemblies

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 11 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R902.1 Roofing covering materials.
Mark Zehnal
 5472 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 3Y – 6N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R902
Mark Zehnal
 5298 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 3Y -6N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R903.2.2 Crickets and saddles.
Mark Zehnal
 5474 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G2 – 6Y – 3N
G3 – 3Y – 6N

G2, G3
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R903.4.1
Mark Zehnal
 5476 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 7Y – 2N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R903.4.2 One and two family dwellings, and private
Mark Zehnal
 5477 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 7Y – 2N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 12 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R903
Mark Zehnal
 5299 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 6Y – 3N
G2 – 3Y -6N

G2, G3
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.10 Metal roof panels.
Mark Zehnal
 5306 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.10.2.1 Underlayment
Mark Zehnal
 5541 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.10.3 Material standards.
Mark Zehnal
 5542 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent

X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).

3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 6Y -3N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.2.6.1 Wind Resistance of Asphalt Shingles.
Mark Zehnal
 5487 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 13 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R905.2.7 Underlayment application.
Mark Zehnal
 5490 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific slope criteria addressed in DEC Statement DCA08‑DEC‑331 and removes unnecessary language.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3 Clay and concrete tile.
Mark Zehnal
 5304 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently A1
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3 Clay and concrete tile.
Mark Zehnal
 5602 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3.2
Mark Zehnal
 5601 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X

A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3.3.1
Mark Zehnal
 5599 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X

A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 14 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R905.3.3.3 Underlayment and high winds.
Mark Zehnal
 5499 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3.3
Mark Zehnal
 5600 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3.6
Mark Zehnal
 5598 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3.7.1
Mark Zehnal
 5596 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3.7
Mark Zehnal
 5597 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1-9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 15 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R905.3.8
Mark Zehnal
 5595 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.3
Mark Zehnal
 5603 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria including update to previous Commission approved code referenced standard.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.4 Metal roof shingles.
Mark Zehnal
 5307 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N
G1 – 0Y 9N

G1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.4.3.2 Underlayment and high winds.
Mark Zehnal
 5507 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.5 Mineral‑surfaced roll roofing.
Mark Zehnal
 5308 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 16 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R905.6 Slate and slate‑type shingles.
Mark Zehnal
 5312 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.6.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5558 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

A1 – 2Y -7N
G1 – 9Y -0N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.6.3.2 Underlayment and high winds.
Mark Zehnal
 5516 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides and carries forward current 2010 FBC Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.7 Wood shingles.
Mark Zehnal
 5315 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y – 0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.7.3 Underlayment..
Mark Zehnal
 5559 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 2Y – 7N
G1 – 7Y – 2N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 17 of 18
12/20/2012

Total Mods for  Roofing in  No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second
TAC: 
Roofing
 62
Section
R905.8 Wood shakes.
Mark Zehnal
 5314 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905.8.3 Underlayment.
Mark Zehnal
 5560 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Incorporates intent of foundation code for attachment of underlayment in high wind section and unifies installation guidelines of underlayment with current Florida‑specific criteria.
9
Proponent
X
X
1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – 2Y – 7N
G1 – 9Y – 0N

A1
Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R905
Mark Zehnal
 5301 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y-0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R907 REROOFING
Mark Zehnal
 5554 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Moves current Florida‑specific criteria from Existing Buildings volume used in residential reroofing to the Residential volume.
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
A1, A4
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
A1 – Vote 7Y – 2N
A4 – Vote 9Y – 0N
A3 – no action needed

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Section
R907
Mark Zehnal
 5316 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Provides current Florida‑specific criteria
9
Proponent
X

1. Support comment. Comment sufficiently 
addresses the TAC's concern(s).
2. Do Not Support comment. 
Comment does not address the TAC's 
concern(s).
G1
3. No comment is needed.
4. Straw Poll.
Commission Action

X
G1 – 9Y -0N

Summary

AS
AM

NAR

I
No Affirmative Recommendation with a Second

W

Search Criteria

ROOFING TAC
WITH COMMENTS

Page 18 of 18
12/20/2012

Modification #:
Code Change Cycle:
Chapter & Topic:
Date Submitted From:
TAC:
Proponent Last Name:
Affects HVHZ:
Sub Code:
Code Version:
Commission Action:
Text of Modification:
Section:
Related Modifications:
TAC Recommendation:
Modification Status:
Date Submitted To:
Proponent First Name:
2013
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
R
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
No
Archived: